On (Not) Belonging and Lineage

Okay, fine, this is raw and wrong, but I’m saying it anyway. Nothing hip checks me out of my fantasies and into reality faster than listening to author bios being read aloud at literary events. After listing the first three to five publications—The Paris Review, The New Yorker, The Atlantic—and however many awards that follow—Tin House, MacDowell, MacArthur—the chip on my shoulder starts to ache. I search for commonalities, ways to connect. My heart whispers, nope, not you, not you again. I look around the room. Where are the other writers? I wonder if anyone but me feels deeply out of place here. I recall the associate at the fancy agency, years ago, saying how good my writing was, how funny, how relatable, and that the agents would never go for it, because their ideas about publishing were limited. “They can’t see past themselves,” he’d said. I think of indie authors BookToking themselves into the market on their own terms, insisting we don’t need the Big 5 Publishers anymore. “That paradigm is dead,” they say.   

At the Portland Book Festival, I sit on the floor of the art gallery listening to young authors talk about the book they wish they’d had when they were new moms, the book that’s in their hands right now, Notes to New Mothers, which they take turns reading from. The writing is insightful, humorous, and heartbreaking. I too saw a blank space on the bookshelf and dreamed of filling it. This was long before Nightbitch, The Push, Madwoman, All Fours, and dozens of other recent titles. I too was a mother writing in the bathroom as four young kids rattled and kicked the door.

Seeing this festival through the eyes of a soon-to-be debut novelist, I felt a little lost. I paid careful attention to that chip on my shoulder—its weight, its history—and, still, the feeling that settled over me was that I didn’t belong.            

On my way to a friend’s pop-up, I inadvertently joined a line for the Whitsell Auditorium. With my usual playfulness, I said, “What is this? What are we lined up for?” My voice was too loud, I guess. Intrusive. “Oh,” snapped a woman slightly older than me, “Okaaaay.” She moved aside, putting what few inches she could afford between us. I’m introvert-aware, I swear. I try to avoid scaring people with my boldness. Sometimes, I fail. Not this time. Maybe I smiled too big. I don’t know. A younger person, seeing the exchange, shared event info with me (a panel for Lisa Hanawalt’s I Can’t Stop Thinking About Horses and Sex). I thanked them and exited the queue. My friend’s pop-up was in the next gallery. But I was mesmerized by a massive, color-saturated, hyper-stimulating digital installation (Heaven’s Gate) and lingered nearby a few seconds. The older woman must have made a joke. Several laughing heads turned my way. I felt their eyes on me. I didn’t presume the joke was about me. Self-centerness is another key awareness of mine. And though I really wanted to know what was funny (I like laughing!), I didn’t risk another question. I felt self conscious enough. My fingers curled into little fists. A portal opened. My seven-year-old self, misfit and friendless, stood like a stone. This was before I learned to be funny, before I learned to fight, before I lost the drive to fit in.   

Do any of us feel like we truly belong? Are artists uniquely—what? predisposed? prone? suited?—to loneliness, to processing the world through creativity? If we don’t process it, do we die? I think, yes. Kind of. We die.

Days after the festival, I got an audio message from a friend who’s currently reading my book. I didn’t ask her to read it. She just kind of … demanded to. Her voice was bubbling over … laughing, cringing, crying, reading on, and, suddenly, proclaiming so many fuckingwomen need this book, truly! She said what I’m telling myself about not belonging isn’t true and I need to work on that. She’s a professional advice-giver so it sounded more directive than suggestive. “You’re wonderful and amazing and you belong in every room you walk into,” she said.

I saved the message.

Not that it matters but—-that’s a lie, it actually does matter, a lot—three whole people whose work I love, respect, and aspire to, who I’m not sleeping with, who I’m not related to, who aren’t one of my two dearest friends, and who aren’t the small press that’s publishing me, have specifically and ethusiastically talked about how much they love my book. Listen, it’s not that I’m defining myself by their praise. I have an absurdly complicated relationship with praise. What it means is the next time, if I can remember, I’m listening to bios I can’t relate to (basically all of them), and that chip on my shoulder begins to weigh me down with wild, destabilizing fictions, I can remind myself that I belong to something very, very special: the Portland literary community. I’m part of a lineage of bold, brave authors who’ve pushed the boundaries of storytelling in astonishing ways. It’s not their resumes that fill my spirit with yes, yes, me, yes, its their words, and, sometimes, it’s their friendship. ‍ ‍

Honoring the lineage of Portland authors, a compilation by Shannon Brazil

Shannon Brazil

Gen X feminist author delving into sex and sexuality, domestic anarchy, grief, motherhood, and other entanglements.

https://www.shannonbrazil.com/home
Previous
Previous

Attempted Murder

Next
Next

Pre-order My Book!